Review:
Barnhill begins The Girl Who Drank the Moon with characters separate from the main story, where a child asks her mother to tell her stories. The mother and child reappear intermittently throughout the book, adding to the reader's understanding of how the legends and views of the Protectorate have come to be. This familial pair helps set the stage for the following action or guides the reader into understanding the "how"s and "why"s of such actions.
Barnhill's world building is phenomenal. Sorrow is a presence in the Protectorate, its absence is pronounced in the Free Cities, and it has a tendency to be a gnat humming in the ear of those in Xan's glade. Barnhill writes a world where possibility, good and bad, is tangible at every turn.
There is much good humor and joy found in the book. Glerk and Fyrian's interactions with the child Luna often caused me to laugh out loud. It is a true coming of age story, and not just for Luna. There are many moments in the story where characters, as Dumbledore says, must choose between what is right and what is easy. It is a story of how we both are, and are not, a product of our environment. It is a story of the bonds that draw family, friends, and communities together. And it is a story of great love and great courage, especially when the Tiger is on the prowl and all that they know and love is at stake.
A fun and fast-paced read, Barnhill's book is for middle grade readers who love magic, mythical creatures, and strong female characters.